Re: [spoon-discuss] The Unused Rules

["Orc In A Spacesuit" <orcinaspacesuit@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Well, besides telling you what I think, I thought I'd go thorugh and also 
state how the uber affects these:

> From: Wonko <dplepage@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> Dave said something about repealing everything that people never use.
>
> Well, I just read through the ruleset, and made a list of everything that,
> IMHO seems useless/never used/used badly. So, straw poll time - Who would 
> be
> opposed to the repealing of the following:
>
> * The second paragraph of Rule 2?
uber absorbs it
> * 1/2 proposals ('cause you can do the same thing with a 2-part A La 
> Carte)?
uber absorbs it
> * The List of Misbehaving Judges?
I think it's a good idea

**All Gremlins
Shortened by the uber

> * The Window Gremlins?
I like them
> * The AAAHHH! Gremlin?
Keeps the game from getting so simple or too outta hand
> * The Player-Wannabe Gremlin?
buggy, but uber fixes it
> * The PIG?
It keeps insta-rules manageable
> * The Pink Scarf?
I like it
> * The Immunity Idol?
Needs reworking; I have some ideas not in the uber; uber shortens it
> * Genders?
I have ideas for this.
> * Siren Bait?
don't care
> * The Yeti (and Frozen Squares)?
I like it
> * Ancient Monoliths?
I think they need reworking
> * Toads?
I have no problem with getting rid of turning players into toads.

**All these different items:
The uber shortens and simplifies a lot

> * Big Sticks?
keep
> * The Shield?
keep
> * Balls of Wax?
keep
> * Athames?
keep
> * The Sledge-O-Matic?
keep
> * Piles of Kindling?
keep
> * Towels?
overpowered
> * Buttplates?
hrm... dunno
> * Football?
it either needs to simplified or cut out.  I standardized it in the uber, 
but would like to cut out some of the complicated stuff.
> * The Upper House?
keep
> * Brooks?
I like them.  Uber simplifies
> * Cinquains?
I like
> * Gnome Replication (the Beer Can type)?
keep
> * Yoyo, Weather, or Sheep Gnomes?
keep
> * Death?
uber gets rid of Death, and makes Catastrophes, or whatever we're gonna call 
them
> * Shears?
keep.  uber simplifies
> * Cotton Swabs?
keep.  don't like the name, though
> * Insta-Rules?
keep
> * Judgment Props?
I don't see much point in them, but they can't hurt.
> * Mentorship? (I've never seen a mentor *do* anything except get paid!)
dunno
> * The Casino?
keep
> * Offers?
uber simplifies a LOT.
> * The LOSA?
keep
> * Bondage?
I really don't care.  Newer players, read the prop that created this for a 
laugh or some head-scratchin'
> * Engravings?
Keep.

Orc wuz here!

> * Unbridled Hostility?
Keep

Watch where you're swinging that scapel, boy.  But I agree, there's several 
things that I would like to cut out but left in the uber just so nobody 
would get all picky about it.

_________________________________________________________________
Internet access plans that fit your lifestyle -- join MSN. 
http://resourcecenter.msn.com/access/plans/default.asp

_______________________________________________
spoon-discuss mailing list
spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-discuss