Daniel Lepage on Sun, 1 Aug 2004 20:46:41 -0500 (CDT)

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]

[spoon-discuss] A Consensus is Reached

Ok, Straw Poll Results

The options were:
	1) Keep the long tags
	2) Use the short tags
	3) Put in new headers
	4) Don't add anything

The votes were:

Wonko: 		3,2,4,1
Phil: 		4,3,2,1
bd: 			4,3,2,1
SkArcher:		1,2,3,4
Teucer: 		2,1,3,4
Sagitta: 		4/2
Glotmorf:		2,4,3,1
Iain: 		2,1,4,3
Zarpint: 		4,3,2,1

Now the question is, what's the best method for tallying votes when various voters used different schemes?

Plurality winner: tie, 4 vs. 2
IRV winner: 2
Condorcet Winner: 2
Borda winner: 2
Approval winner: 2 (assuming each player approves of their first two picks)

I believe 2 is the winner, and thus the subjects should have [s-d] and [s-b] inserted instead of [spoon-business] and [spoon-discuss]


History will be kind to me, for I intend to write it.

spoon-discuss mailing list