spoon-discuss: Re: spoon-business: Proposal: This ruleset isn't big enough for the both of us!

[Wonko <dplepage@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Quoth Dan,

> 
> {{
> __This Ruleset isn't big enough for the both of us!__
> 
> Enact the following new rule:
> {{
> __Opposed Proposals__
> 
> A proposal may be specified as being "opposed to" another proposal
> or rule.  This may be specified by including the phrase "In Opposition to
> Proposal xxx" where xxx is the serial number or title of a proposal.
> 
> If proposal b is opposed to proposal a then proposal a is considered to be
> in opposition to proposal b.
> 
> Of any pair of mutually opposed proposals at most one can be enacted.  If
> more than one proposal of any opposed pair passes the proposal that
> recieved the fewest affirmitave votes of the pair becomes inactive and is
> not enacted.
> 
> [[ 
> If opposed proposals a and b pass with 5 and 4 votes in favor,
> respectively, then a is enacted and b is not.
> 
> If mutually opposed proposals a, b, and c pass with 5, 3, and 4 votes
> in favor, respectively, then a is enacted and b and c are not.
> 
> if a is opposed to b and b is opposed to c then a is not nescessarily
> opposed to c.
> 
> if a and b are opposed and a passes with 5 votes in favor but b does not
> pass even with 7 votes in favor then a is enacted and b is not.
> 
> if a is opposed to b and c, but b and c are not mutually opposed, and b
> and c both pass but a does not then b and c are both enacted.
> 
> }}
> 
> Dan
> 
What if a and b both have 5 votes? And where's the ]]?
-- 
Fac ut gaudeam.