Re: spoon-discuss: RFJ

[Jeff Schroeder <jeffs@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

Sounds ok to me, but this will be up to the Judges.  When they get 
picked!  I don't really care about the 'to Randal' part, but just the fact 
that the rule could be ignored so easily and with very weak justification 
via a possible (to be determined) technicality.  This technicality should 
have been brought up by Joel as soon as the Rule was passed in order to 
avoid this kind of problem!  :)  And it is important that the Judge make a 
good ruling here as to determine with more certainty what really defines 
how to identify a Player!  I would say that we all know the Player Joel to 
be Joel Uckelman and I would think difficulties would arise in the future 
if this was ruled to be false. Rule 208/1 might have implications to this.

jeff

At 11:05 AM 3/6/01, you wrote:
> Since my proposal passed, the verb "to Randal" has been defined within the
> game. Thus, all Joel has to do to fulfill the requirement of the rule is to
> take a picture. Of anything. Since I assume he has no particular desire to 
> take
> a picture, and it is rather unrelated to the game, it would be a picture 
> of him
> Randalling. And, of course, he has to upload it to the web site.
>
> --
> Rob Speer


Shop online without a credit card
http://www.rocketcash.com
RocketCash, a NetZero subsidiary