[s-b] Consultation 139

[0x44 <bnomic@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

I answer Consultation 139 NO.

Reasoning:

    A cursory examination of rule 4e33 shows that Currencies are not 
game objects, but instead are an Attribute of the class of game objects 
called Currency Owning Objects. From 4e11, Attributes are not Game 
Objects. Since the Rules of B Nomic does not recognize any Currency 
Objects, it is impossible to destroy Currency (and hence Mackerel) in 
any fashion. The argument that rule 4e73 creates that ability in Guilty 
Parties fails, also. By Rule 4e75, since neither rule 4e33 or 4e73 claim 
precedence over the other, Rule 4e33 takes precedence because of its 
lower rule number. Since that is the case, the clause in 4e73 creating 
the ability to destroy mackerel must be invalid.

Oracularity:
{
    Strike the following sentence from Rule 4e73:
    {
       When the Judge Assigns a Punishment of a fine in macks the Guilty 
Player is obligated and is able to destroy that number of macks for no 
effect. Any Player who has not fulfilled their obligation to destroy 
macks as a result of a punishment is not a Registered Voter.
    }
}

-- 
--
0x44;

_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business