[s-b] Triller Votes

["Mark Walsh" <flutesultan@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

I vote thusly:

> 45      Transactional Proposals  Peter
FOR

> 46      Thrids                   Peter
AGAINST
If the voting period were defined as the beginning and
end of the Third Thrid (as defined in the prop) I can see it.

> 47      Virtual particles        bd
AGAINST
This appears to be self limiting by defining score as
sum of Points and Anti-Points, and later altering the
winning condition to a 'score' greater then 100.
Prop 48 would gut that limit, but this Prop lists 48
as being in Conflict (the first such usage, I believe).
It also Conflicts with my Zeroth Prop (offered so as
not to have to deal with a negative value, which the
text of the current Rule 2-6 can create, and also
Rule Tag (should it pass) can create).

> 48      Generalized Victory      Wonko
FOR

> 49      More Ways to Win         Wonko
FOR

> 50      Anyone care for Dessert? Wonko
FOR

> 51      wtf                      The Dave
AGAINST

> 52      RFJ system, take 2       Antonio
AGAINST
I pulled out my ERA 2 ruleset and can't imagine why
the level of complexity introduced here is called for.

> 53      The Zeroth Addendum      Triller
FOR

> 54      Tags                     comex
AGAINST
Let's just call things what we already call them.

> 55      Rule Tag                 Optional
AGAINST
And not because I dislike the concept. Indeed,
I find it quite intriguing (as I have from its
introduction). I feel that it could still use some
refinement to eliminate a couple of ambiguities,
as well as some grammatical amendment. I'll post
a pick-apart next nweek (haven't had time, what
with the holidays and all). It's almost there.

> 56      the formatting prop      comex
AGAINST
What Wonko said.

> 57      supreme antoniocracy     Antonio
AGAINST
What else?

> 58      Proposal Fix             Wonko
FOR

> 59      New Numbers              Wonko
FOR
Why not?

> 60      days have a name too     Antonio
FOR
Sam ting.

Triller

_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business