Re: [s-d] [s-b] Proposal: Devices

[shadowfirebird@xxxxxxxxx]

> suppose i have an object called, "the voodoo doll" that is triggerable
> by sticking a pin into it.
> any ambiguity in the whole rules (and without looking very far "room for
> choice" is ambiguous itself) would let me decide what happens when i
> trigger the doll, so i could award myself a win, or worse, just by
> sticking a pin into the doll.

Well, yes.

But (1): the devices rule states that the voodoo doll rule must
describe the effect.

But (2): I wouldn't vote for a proposal that created that device, and
neither would you.  Or, I suspect, anyone else.  The "WTF" is in
"Voodoo Doll", not in "Devices".


(BTW I like the idea of a voodoo doll - not the one you used in your
example, obviously - so I've added it to my "shop" proposal; which
I'll release once everyone has had a chance to comment on Devices.)
_______________________________________________
spoon-discuss mailing list
spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-discuss