[s-d] Comments on Props

[Daniel Lepage <dpl33@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

On Oct 23, 2004, at 1.28 PM, wonko@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:

> Wonko's votes:
> Proposal 1917/0: Get off the couch!                          :   
> Abstain
> Proposal 1918/0: Home is where you hang your hat             :   Yes
> Proposal 1919/1: Down to Brass Tax                           :   No

This too vague - I could see this being interpreted as a Tax on 
Charters, for example.

> Proposal 1920/1: Piece on Nomic                              :   No

I'd rather not give any player the ability to destroy all pieces 
anywhere just by pointing. And I'd prefer a game more based on strategy 
than on pieces that randomly destroy other pieces.

> Proposal 1921/0: Sauce                                       :   Shelve

At the moment, there isn't any record of how many times each player's 
been hit with a tomato; if you want this to apply to total hits, I 
think you should explicitly say that somebody needs to keep track of 
who's been hit how many times.

> Proposal 1922/0: Making tomatoes finite                      :   Yes
> Proposal 1923/0: The Drunk                                   :   
> Abstain
Given that this isn't in a literary form at all, you could have at 
least phrased it more readably...

> Proposal 1924/0: Pay for your piece                          :   Shelve

Unfortunately I think this really does need your fix that came in too 
late. Also, the 'destroyer' is usually another piece, though it might 
be a card at some point as well, and sometimes there might be pieces 
destroyed by things that can't hold the bonuses. So I'd prefer if it 
said something like 'when a player takes an action that destroys a 
piece, the bank gives that player the destruction cost of the piece'.

> Proposal 1925/0: untitled                                    :   Shelve

So I'm allowed to suddenly possess any object? Including, for example, 
you and your vines?

> Proposal 1926/1: Conditional Triggers                        :   
> Abstain
> Proposal 1927/1: Less is More: The Admin                     :   Yes
>
> This Message was sent automatically by the Wiki.
>  Please do not reply to this message, as your replies will be ignored. 
> Thank you.

--
Wonko

"How can you govern a country which has 246 varieties of cheese?"
	-Charles De Gaulle

_______________________________________________
spoon-discuss mailing list
spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-discuss