Re: [spoon-discuss] Re: [Spoon-business] CFI -- Dropping da Big One

["Glotmorf" <glotmorf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 10/4/02 at 6:52 PM Wonko wrote:

>Quoth Glotmorf,
>
>> I make the following CFI:
>>
>> Statement:
>>
>> Points, shillings, units of raw material, big sticks, balls of wax,
>athames,
>> piles of kindling, towels, large and small lumps of scrap metal, pinball
>guns,
>> gnomes, beer cans, alcoholic beverages, shears, cotton sponges, bonus
>boxes,
>> shares of stock and airspeeders ceased to exist as of the beginning of
>nweek
>> 24.
>>
>> Analysis:
>>
>> The above objects, within their respective types, are indistinguishable
>from
>> one another.  They are all defined with rules whose Chutzpah is 1.
>>
>> Rule 2 states all game entities must have uniquely identifying names.
>>
>> Therefore, the objects mentioned above did not exist as of the beginning
>of
>> nweek 24.
>
>Seems to me that a better interpretation might be that your proposal failed
>to create rule 6, on the grounds that 'Entity' was already defined in such
>a
>way that this wasn't an issue, and by altering r6, your proposal was
>violation r2 by making it so that there were entities without unique names.
>
>Side note: If Mr. Morf's interpretation stands, then we also don't have a
>Grid. Or more accurately, we have a Grid, but it has no Grid Squares or
>Surface Squares, 'cause they're all non-uniquely named. But that's okay,
>because the interpretation is bogus anyway.

Of course grid squares are uniquely named.  Each is uniquely identified by its (x,y) position.  That's why I didn't include service malls either, because each is uniquely identified as the service mall at (x,y).  Same with Big Rocks.  Sirens have names.  Gnome bags are one per player, therefore each gnome bag is <Player X>'s gnome bag.  Lots of things are uniquely named.  But points aren't.

Funny that you're saying my proposal would have failed to create rule 6.  According to your logic in other arguments, I can create proposals, and proposals can change the ruleset any way they want.  Can't have it both ways, dude.

						Glotmorf


_______________________________________________
spoon-discuss mailing list
spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-discuss