Re: [s-b] [Registrar] Census

[C-walker <charles.w.walker@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On Mon, May 18, 2009 at 7:31 PM, Geoffrey Spear<wooble@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> Registrar's Census
>
> Date of last report: Mon 11 May 09
> Date of this report: Mon 18 May 09
>
> (All times are UTC)
>
> Recent events
> -------------
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - C-Walker registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - Murphy registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - Codae registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - Billy Pilgrim registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - Wooble registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - 0x44 registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - JamesB registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - ais523 registered by Refresh
> Mon 11 May 17:39:32 - Teucer registered by Refresh
> ---- time of last report ----
> Tue 12 May 06:42:02 - Tiger registers (to S-B, marked public)
> Tue 12 May 19:06:41 - BobTHJ registers (to S-B, marked public)
> Wed 13 May 18:00:00 - comex registers (to S-B, marked public)
> Fri 15 May 15:31:57 - ehird registers
> Sun 17 May 22:07:11 - Tiger ratifies S-B into a Public forum
>
> FIRST-CLASS PLAYERS (13)
>
> Nickname                E-mail address                   Since
> --------------------------------------------------------------------
> 0x44                    bnomic@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx            11 May 2009
> ais523                  ais523@xxxxxxxxxx                11 May 2009
> Billy Pilgrim           bad.leprechaun@xxxxxxxxx         11 May 2009
> BobTHJ                  pidgepot@xxxxxxxxx               12 May 2009
> Codae                   quesmarktion@xxxxxxxxxxxxx       11 May 2009
> comex                   comexk@xxxxxxxxx                 13 May 2009
> C-Walker                charles.w.walker@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx  11 May 2009
> ehird                   penguinofthegods@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx  15 May 2009
> JamesB                  jebaxter@xxxxxxxxxxxxx           11 May 2009
> Murphy                  emurphy42@xxxxxxxxxxxx           11 May 2009
> Teucer                  teucer@xxxxxxxxx                 11 May 2009
> Tiger                   jonatan.kilhamn@xxxxxxxxx        12 May 2009
> Wooble                  wooble@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx            11 May 2009
>
> Fora:  (PF = Public Forum, DF = Discussion Forum)
>
>  PF <spoon-business@xxxxxxxxxxx>    (business)
>  DF <spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxx>     (discussion)

I intend, without objection, to ratify the above incorrect document.
It is incorrect because Ais523's RP accidentally registered anyone who
had ever voted on any refresh proposal. This has mostly likely
inflated quorum higher than the number of actual players and prevented
any proposal passing since the last emergency. Luckily, Agora's rules
defend us well against another crisis and this ratification will
retroactively fix everything.

Apologies if you know all the above already.

Relevant discussion from ##nomic:

<c-walker> btw, i think ais523's RP broke B
<Wooble> it;s not broken, it's in a lull.
<ais523> Wooble and I both believe that B is platonically broken
<ais523> c-walker: do you mean rules-wise?
<Wooble> the problem is that agora doesn't have much gameplay in its
ruleset, and we're all too lazy to start a contest.
<c-walker> i mean it flipped the citizenship of any entity who ever
voted on an RP to registered, possibly inflating quorum beyond that
which would allow any of the recent proposals to pass
<ais523> isn't the current major activity adding the loopholes back in?
<ais523> c-walker: ooh, really? it wasn't meant to
<ais523> we can ratify the players list without objection, though
<ais523> Agora's ruleset is rather robust against that sort of thing

-- 
C-walker
Statements made in this message may or may not be false
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business