Re: [s-b] Ballot for nweek 129

["Geoffrey Spear" <geoffspear@xxxxxxxxx>]

I vote as follows:

> Proposal   Author                     Title
> 141           Wooble                   Fix Faction Loophole
FOR [The reason that this is a loophole is that as it's written the
rule doesn't actually require the Faction to decide to join B Nomic; a
Player can cause an Agreement to join as a Faction unilaterally unless
the Agreement specifically forbids it]

> 142           Peter                      We're from the future, and
> we're here to help
AGAINST

> 143           Wooble                   Spivak is not English
FOR

> 144           bad_leprechaun     The Ministry of Goods
FOR [a bit confusing, but I'm willing to try it out; it can always be
amended if it turns out to be too unwieldy]

> 145           Wooble                   Trying to track previously
> failed proposals by a given Author is a pain
AGAINST [I'm convinced, I guess, but I think 2-6 is badly worded; I
took it to mean that in 3 different nweeks in the past a Player could
have had a proposal that was both Failed and never Won in that nweek]

> 146           bad_leprechaun     Legislative Dominance don't come cheap
FOR

> 147           Charles                   Priestly Indecision
AGAINST

> 148           Eugene Meidinger  Eugene never wins
AGAINST [Neither does anyone else but Charles, and I'm not willing to
turn this into an Imperial Nomic just to let someone else get a win
for once]

> 149           Charles                   No More Membership Tests!
FOR

-Wooble


-- 
Geoffrey Spear
http://www.geoffreyspear.com/
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business