[s-b] Open CFI's

[Rainbow Wolfe <rainbowdreamwolf@xxxxxxxxx>]

Raelus vs. Eugene, Nweek 88 

*Plaintiff:* Raelus 

*Statement:* Proposal 84 does not exist. Any gamestate changes in it cannot 
be made. 

*Analysis by Plaintiff:* The rules state that players can only have 5 
pending/open proposals at any one time. Eugene's Talisman is still a ball of 
energy, so it has no effect on this. Since 84 is the sixth proposal, 
creating it was an illegal game action.
 
I rule REFUSED. If proposal 84 doesn't exist then no changes can be made. 
This makes the CFI nonsensical and open to much abuse: including the already 
suggested CFI by BvS / Wonko. I do agree with the analysis though.
 Nice try, Peter. 

*Plaintiff:* EugeneMeidinger<http://www.bnomic.org/cgi-bin/moin.cgi/EugeneMeidinger>

*Defendant:* Peter 

*Statement:* Peter's proprosal doesn't actually propose anything, is full of 
nonsense, makes no reference to the game and plagerized. Therefore p74 is 
invalid. 

*Analysis by Plaintiff:* The rules say that each Proposal consists of a list 
of Gamestate Changes, that is, changes to the state and/or existence of some 
number of Game Objects. P74 contains one line in the interrogative form and 
the rest are declarative. A proposal needs statments in the imperative form 
in order to command any changes to the gamestate. Now even though one is 
allowed to use a declarative to demonstrate the existence of a game object 
this proposal does not even do that. This proposal does not reference any 
existing game objects nor does it declare the existence of new ones. Instead 
is it full of lines about eternal summer and rough winds and other such 
rubbish. I therefore find this proposal not meeting its requirements of a 
proposal and has nothing to do with the game.
 
I rule FOR. This proposal doesn't propose anything, and as long as 
Permissibility of the Indistinguishable doesn't exist i don't believe there 
is anything that makes direct reference to empty props.
 
- Rainbow Wolfe
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business