[Spoon-business] NWEEK 56 RESULTS

["David E. Smith" <dave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Note: These are the official results, but I haven't yet had time to update
the Roster to reflect Score and Dimension changes (as summarized at the
very bottom). I want to get some sleep, quite frankly. I'll try to get
them typed in later today, but I really wanted to get the vote results out
so we can move on with nweek 57.

Proposals:
"Put that back!" is p1771/0.
"Platonism" is p1773/0.
"Opposites of Platonism" is p1774/0.
"The Conan Paradox" is p1775/0.

CFI Stuff:
* SkArcher submits an analysis on CFI 1748, but never included a TRUE or
  FALSE statement. Based on reading the analysis, though, I'm assuming
  it's TRUE.
* Teucer submits analysis on CFI 1748, but no valid ruling. (This is later
  amended to Refused.)
* The Pusher Robot submits a ruling on CFI 1748 (Refused).
* Zarpint attempts to make a CFI, but as there are multiple Statements, it's
  not a valid CFI.
* Zarpint makes a second CFI (about Rule 10), CFI 1772, assigned to Rob.

Card stuff:
Sagitta draws a card (Your Spoo Has Too Much Fleem).

Nweek stuff:
Everyone is dealt a new Card. They're all on the Web site.
The new Gremlin Number is 44.


Proposal 1756/0 (Age before Beauty) (Wonko):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, SkArcher, Wonko
NEG: Glotmorf, Mikie The Inscrutable, Teucer, Zarpint
ABS: bd
SHL: Sagitta, The Pusher Robot
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (3-4-1-2). Measure fails. Measure is shelved.
Created p1776/0.

Proposal 1757/2 (For the Love of Bob) (The Pusher Robot):
AFF: Mikie The Inscrutable, Teucer, The Pusher Robot, Zarpint
NEG: Baron von Skippy, Glotmorf, Sagitta, SkArcher x2, Wonko
ABS: bd
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (4-6-1-0). Measure fails. The Pusher Robot loses 2 points.
The Admin breathes a sigh of relief. :-)

Proposal 1758/0 (Repeal of the LOSA) (Wonko):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Sagitta, The Pusher Robot, Wonko
NEG: Glotmorf, Mikie The Inscrutable, SkArcher, Teucer, Zarpint
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (5-5-0-0). Measure fails. Wonko loses 1 points.

Proposal 1759/1 (The Council Revisited) (Wonko):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, SkArcher, Wonko
NEG: Glotmorf, Sagitta, Teucer, Zarpint
SHL: The Pusher Robot
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (5-4-0-1). Measure fails. Measure is shelved.

Proposal 1760/0 (Political Tafl) (Teucer):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable
NEG: SkArcher, Teucer, Zarpint
ABS: Glotmorf
SHL: Sagitta, The Pusher Robot, Wonko
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (3-3-1-3). Measure fails. Measure is shelved.
Created p1777/0.

Proposal 1761/0 (Allowing Actions Again) (Wonko):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, The Pusher Robot, Wonko
NEG: Glotmorf, Sagitta, Teucer, Zarpint
ABS: SkArcher
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (5-4-1-0). Measure passes. Wonko gains 8 points.
Created r1638/1.

Proposal 1762/0 (Standardized Elections) (Wonko):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, SkArcher, The Pusher Robot
NEG: Sagitta, Teucer, Wonko, Zarpint
SHL: Glotmorf
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (5-4-0-1). Measure fails. Measure is shelved.
Created p1778/0.

Proposal 1764/1 (Nevinyrral's Disk) (SkArcher):
AFF: SkArcher
NEG: Baron von Skippy, Glotmorf, Mikie The Inscrutable, Teucer, Wonko, Zarpint
ABS: bd, The Pusher Robot
SHL: Sagitta
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (1-6-2-1). Measure fails. SkArcher loses 4 points.

Proposal 1765/0 (Untitled Prop by SkArcher) (SkArcher):
AFF: SkArcher, The Pusher Robot
NEG: Baron von Skippy, Glotmorf, Mikie The Inscrutable, Sagitta, Teucer,
     Wonko, Zarpint
ABS: bd
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (2-7-1-0). Measure fails. SkArcher loses 2 points.

Proposal 1766/0 (Gender Fix) (Zarpint):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, Sagitta, The Pusher
     Robot, Zarpint
NEG: Glotmorf, Teucer
ABS: SkArcher, Wonko
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (6-2-2-0). Measure passes. Zarpint gains 12 points.
Created r295/5.

Proposal 1767/0 (Pseudocoding is not a crime) (Zarpint):
AFF: Teucer, The Pusher Robot x3, Zarpint
NEG: Baron von Skippy, Glotmorf, Mikie The Inscrutable, SkArcher, Wonko
SHL: bd, Sagitta
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (5-5-0-2). Measure fails. Zarpint loses 4 points.

Proposal 1768/1 (Rewarding Strangeness) (Zarpint):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, Teucer, The Pusher
     Robot, Wonko, Zarpint
NEG: Glotmorf, Sagitta, SkArcher
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (7-3-0-0). Measure passes. Zarpint gains 10 points.
Created r23/5.

Proposal 1769/0 (Attributes are very Stylish) (Zarpint):
AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, Sagitta, SkArcher,
     Wonko, Zarpint
NEG: Teucer
ABS: The Pusher Robot
SHL: Glotmorf
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (7-1-1-1). Measure passes. Zarpint gains 9 points.
Created r154/28.

Proposal 1770/0 (Once More, With Less Suckage) (Baron von Skippy):
AFF: Baron von Skippy x2, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, The Pusher Robot, Zarpint
NEG: Glotmorf, Sagitta, SkArcher x3, Teucer, Wonko
Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (6-6-0-0). Measure fails. Baron von Skippy loses 3 points.

Affirmative vote counts (BW Grem):
Wonko: 23 votes
The Pusher Robot: 4 votes
Teucer: 3 votes
SkArcher: 3 votes
Zarpint: 23 votes
Baron von Skippy: 5 votes

Contrary vote counts (1pt per):
Zarpint: 4 votes
Mikie The Inscrutable: 2 votes
Teucer: 5 votes
The Pusher Robot: 5 votes
Wonko: 1 votes
Sagitta: 3 votes
bd: 2 votes
Baron von Skippy: 2 votes
Glotmorf: 3 votes
SkArcher: 3 votes

Psychic vote counts (IOB):
Glotmorf: 6 votes
Wonko: 8 votes
Sagitta: 5 votes
SkArcher: 5 votes
Baron von Skippy: 8 votes
Zarpint: 6 votes
Mikie The Inscrutable: 8 votes
Teucer: 5 votes
The Pusher Robot: 3 votes
bd: 4 votes

Plus Points:
Wonko: 8
Zarpint: 31

Minus Points:
The Pusher Robot: 2
Wonko: 1
SkArcher: 6
Zarpint: 4
Baron von Skippy: 3

Plus Props:
Wonko: 1
Zarpint: 3

Minus Props:
The Pusher Robot: 1
Wonko: 1
SkArcher: 2
Zarpint: 1
Baron von Skippy: 1
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business