spoon-business: CFJ447 and my votes

["Alex Truelsen" <a_skywalker85@xxxxxxxxxxx>]

I just realized that I sent my votes to the wrong place. Frip. Okay, I vote 
"Yes" on all proposals. There we go.

CFJ 447/0
CFJ by Scoff!
Assigned Judge: Uncle Psychosis (misbehaved)
Reassigned Judge: Baron von Skippy

Statement: The Token Of Proposals was not awarded to The Voice. It was 
awarded to Scoff!

Rationale: As the Administrator pointed out, declarations of Respect are not 
Proposals for the purpose of scoring. Ergo, there's an established custom in 
the rules that declarations of respect shouldn't earn the author a reward.

Judgement: TRUE

Analysis: What Scoff! said, for one. Also, if we let votes for respect count 
as votes towards the Token of Proposals, then we'd have respect cropping up 
all over the place, as people try to grab yes votes. And that would get 
annoying, fast.

                                             Cheers,
                                               BvS

"Your point is if you light a match near your calculator, it's not going to 
scurry away.
It's all relative. A big fire for Deep Blue, a little match for a little 
calculator."

                           -Murray Foster of Moxy Früvous

_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp.