| ID Scott on 29 Jan 2002 22:38:37 -0000 |
[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Date Index] [Thread Index]
| spoon-business: Hopefully completely fathomable CFJ: spoon-discuss: Re: Proosal |
Statement: (1) This CFJ is permited by the rule 129, (2) and Rule 10 is not repealed. Analysis: As regard to point (2) ,Rule 18 states that deletion of a rule is not permited and unregulated, and hence is regulated (or arguably, prohibited, but in this case, we couldnt delete any rules!). Rule 11 states that "the ruleset can only be changed as provided therein", and as the ruleset does not provide for rule changes by players using non-proposal actions (e.g. Uncle Psychosis post sig "action"), no change occoured, and hence no action actually happened, hence Rule 129 (the statute of limitations) did not kick in (it states that player actions which _happened_ become legal) hence this CFJ is permitted (which deals with point (1)) Admitedly, that is a slightly circular argument, but the best I could do at this time of night. cheers, Iain On Tue, 29 Jan 2002, Gavin Doig wrote: > > <proosal> > > <title>You can't even see.</title> > > <body> > > Amend rule 212, if it exists, by > > replacing "three" with "5". > > [[If 266 fails, at least we'll have an > > alternative.]] > > </body> > > </proosal> > > > > uin. > > I repeal rule 10! > > > It's now been (over) an nweek since I performed the above actions. Therefore, they are considered to be legal (by rule 129), and rule 10 is no more (or possibly has been no more since then, but it doesn't matter at the moment which). > > Possible reasons for this to fail: > CFJ136 - not relevant, as that CFJ was submitted and judged *before* the statute kicked in. > R152 - it *is* permitted by the rules (specifically, r129 permits it). > The fact that my action came after my signature - there's nothing to prohibit this, and we have the precedent of the admin recognising my point transfers of yesterday, which also came after my sig. What a convenient coincidence ;-) > > uin. > -- > > _______________________________________________ > Sign-up for your own FREE Personalized E-mail at Mail.com > http://www.mail.com/?sr=signup > > Win a ski trip! > http://www.nowcode.com/register.asp?affiliate=1net2phone3a > > >