spoon-business: Call for Judgement

[Jörg Rathlev <joerg@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

> We haven't had a CFJ in a while.
>
> --
> The Kid

Ok. Here's two:

--
Call for Judgement

Statement:

Debts are not Objects as defined by Rule 316/0.


Analysis:

Rule 347/0 states that "Debts are objects" (note the lowercase spelling of "objects"). Rule 347/0 also states that "Debts are divisible", but Objects as defined by Rule 316/0 are "indivisible".

I conclude that debts are not Objects as defined by Rule 316/0.
--


and the second:

--
Call for Judgement

Statement:

NomicHomes cannot be transferred.


Analysis:

Rule 316/0 states that "Objects (...) may not be transferred (...) except as allowed by the Rules".

Rule 340/0 defines that a NomicHome is an instance of a Place. Places are defined by Rule 327/0, which does not allow them to be transferred.

Rule 340/0 includes the following statement:

"NomicHomes can be bought and sold in the same manner as any Object".

In this statement, "any Object" refers to Objects in general, i.e. Objects as defined by Rule 316/0, which cannot be transferred. Thus the statement defines that NomicHomes cannot be transferred.
--


Joerg