Re: [s-d] Re: [auto] Antonio votes

[Antonio Dolcetta <zagarna@xxxxxxxxx>]

Daniel Lepage wrote:
> So, at the end of the Voting Period, every Open prop becomes Historical 
> (3-3) and thus resolves (2-6). Now the changes are implemented in 
> ascending serial number order (2-6), and at exactly the same time 
> everyone gets Amplitude (3-4).
>
> Since r2-6 takes precedence over r3-4 (by r2-2), the effects of r2-6 all 
> happen before the effects of r3-4 (by r2-5).
>
> Hence, each prop has its gamestate changing effects in order, meaning 
> that p214 gives Amplitude, and then p266 removes them all; after this 
> has all happened, we all simultaneously gain all the Amplitude from 
> voting under r3-4 (and all form bonuses from r3-9), so these bonuses are 
> unaffected by p266.
>
> Thus, IMHO, we should begin next nweek each having exactly as much 
> Amplitude as r3-4 and r3-9 say we should get.
>
> --Wonko

I think you're right. I got misled by the "the changes are made 
sequentially in ascending serial number order." in rule 2-6.
The changes referred to are only those explicitly stated in the passing 
motion, point awarding is resolved afterwards as per standard precedence 
rules.

Sorry for the noise !

--

	Antonio
    http://gelo.dolcetta.net
_______________________________________________
spoon-discuss mailing list
spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-discuss