[s-d] Win Attempt....DENIED

[eugman@xxxxxxxxxxx]

> Rule 3-12 states that "Any player may Win at any time by declaring so
> in a public forum, but only if a sentence in the Ruleset other than
> this one explicitly permits it."
> 
> Rule 1-3's last paragraph states that "A text to the effect that "any
> player may do X" should be interpreted to mean that X is a Game
> Action."
> 
> Thus, Winning is a Game Action, as long as a sentence besides the one
> in r3-12 permits it.

Sound reasonable.

> Rule 1-3's first paragraph states that "Any Outsider may take any Game
> Action at any time unless the rules say otherwise."

Nice try but no cigar.  It doesn't mention winning  in there anywhere so it isn't explicitly mentioning. I can go into a deeper rebuttal if you like. 


_______________________________________________
spoon-discuss mailing list
spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-discuss