Re: [spoon-discuss] Barrel O' Proposals-- RFC

["Glotmorf" <glotmorf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 7/22/02 at 4:45 PM The Voice wrote:

>This is a request for comments-- I was thinking about tying this into the
>mentor pool somehow, but I wanted to make it open to everyone.  Any
>thoughts, my esteemed colleagues?
>
>
>{{ __I Hate Nomic-Player's Block!__
>
>Create a new rule entitled __The Barrel O' Proposals__ {*Proposal, 2*},
>with
>the following -0- delimited text:
>
>-0-
>There exists a game entity known as The Barrel O' Proposals, or just The
>Barrel.  Any player may at any point place a proposal in The Barrel by
>submitting it to a public forum, explicitly stating that it is for The
>Barrel.  A proposal in The Barrel does not count against its author's
>bandwidth, nor is it placed on the Ballot.  All proposals in The Barrel
>must
>be available for public viewing.  Any player may at any point Claim a
>proposal in The Barrel which was not authored by them by stating that they
>do so in a public forum.  A proposal Claimed by a player is treated as if
>it
>was authored by them, with the following restrictions:
>
>1) 1/3 of the points gained or lost by the proposal, rounded up, are
>gained
>or lost by its original author [[the player who placed it in the Barrel]].
>
>The remainder of the points are gained or lost by the player who Claimed
>it.
>

Ooo.  Proposal ghosting. :)

>2) The proposal may not be significantly altered to the point at which the
>intent of the original author is lost.  If the original author believes
>that
>this has happened, e may inform the Administrator to that regard.  The
>Administrator then decides whether this has occurred.  If the
>Administrator
>decides that it has, then the changed proposal cannot be placed on the
>Ballot, and the Claiming player loses 10 points to the original author.
>If
>the Administrator decides that it has not, then the original author loses
>10
>points to the Claiming player.

What happens to the claimed proposal once the Administrator rules in favor of the original author?  Does it remain removed from the barrel, or is it placed back in?

						Glotmorf


_______________________________________________
spoon-discuss mailing list
spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-discuss