Re: spoon-discuss: Re: spoon-business: Proposal-Messing with the System

["Glotmorf" <glotmorf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 5/9/02 at 9:43 PM Glotmorf wrote:

>On 5/9/02 at 9:23 PM Wonko wrote:
>
>>I issue the following Charter Prop:
>>
>>{{
>>__Let's get some points!__
>>
>>[[This is a Charter Prop. It could be far more nefarious, but I don't want
>>to cause trouble - I just want to point out what's wrong with Charter
>>Props.
>>Basically, everyone who votes for this gets 20 points if it passes, and
>>only
>>1/3 of the players need to vote yes for it to pass. Just take the points
>>and
>>run.]]
>>
>>Create:
>>
>>{{
>>__Points for All!__
>>
>>There exists a Society called the Holy Order of Points.
>>
>>Every player who voted for the proposal which created this rule is
>>initially
>>a member of the Holy Order of Points.
>>
>>New players may join by announcing eir intention to do so on a Public
>>Forum;
>>Any member of the Holy Order of Points may be kicked out by any other
>>member
>>of the Holy Order of Points. [[This is irrelevant anyway]]
>>
>>The Holy Order of Points may not submit Club Props.
>>
>>If at any time 1/3 or more of all players are members of the Holy Order of
>>Points, all members of the Holy Order of Points gain 20 points and are
>>immediately ousted from the club. [[and then, because it has no members,
>>the
>>Club is disbanded as per r578]]
>>
>>Wonko is the First Member of the Holy Order of Points.
>>}}
>>}}
>>--
>>Wonko
>
>Gee...I'm tempted to CFJ it and say it was in violation of r155. :)
>
>						Glotmorf

I take that back.  This is actually a violation of r631, courtesy of the changes I made last nweek, replacing "includes" with "consists of".  The charter prop rule says a charter prop "consists of" the items listed there.  Since nothing in that list mentioned awarding points to members for any reason, your proposal contains stuff that makes it not qualify as a charter prop.  Sorry, guy.

						Glotmorf