Re: spoon-discuss: CFJ

["Glotmorf" <glotmorf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 4/24/02 at 7:14 PM Wonko wrote:

>Quoth Glotmorf,
>
>> This is in my mailbox...
>>
>> *********** REPLY SEPARATOR  ***********
>>
>> On 4/19/02 at 11:31 PM Wonko wrote:
>>
>>> This will be sent out as soon as the Clock's on
>>>
>>> <CFJ>
>>>
>>> Statement: Once a player has cast a vote on a proposal, e may not change
>>> it.
>>>
>>> Defendant: None
>>>
>>> Analysis by Plaintiff:
>>>
>>> Rule 31 states "During Voting, players may change eir vote on a given
>issue
>>> by submitting a different vote for that issue."
>>>
>>> However, the above process for changing votes is impossible to use, as a
>>> lower numbered rule, rule 30, states that "Each Player may cast exactly
>one
>>> vote on each proposal on any given Ballot."
>>>
>>> Since submitting a different vote is forbidden, players may not change
>eir
>>> votes.
>>> </CFJ>
>>>
>>> --
>>> Wonko
>>
>>
>
>Check who it was sent to... "Spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx"
>--
>Wonko

Hm.  Fair enough.  Still, my CFJ wasn't based on your CFJ, existent or non.  It was based on Congenital Optimist's judgment of it, which exists whether it was based on a real or an imaginary CFJ.  I'm happy with her reasoning, and use it as the basis of my CFJ.

						Glotmorf