Re: spoon-discuss: Re: spoon-business: CFJ

[Wonko <dplepage@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Quoth Tyler Crosby,

> 
>> But if a judge decides that they were "created" by these rules, then the
>> following things never happened:
>> 
>> 465/0 passes (4-3-1).
>> Created 492/0.
>> Created 293/2.
>> The Voice scores 10 points.
>> Created The Golden-Armed Gremlin.
>> 
> -0- Amended the r293 (or whichever rule) appropriately. -0-
No, the *proposal* to create the rule changed r293. The *rule* which
"created" the Gremlin didn't, and therefore was illegal by r293.

>> 483/0 passes (6-1-1).
>> Created The Five-Star General Gremlin.
>> Created 499/0.
>> The Voice scores 8 points.
>> 
> -0- Doesn't affect players DIRECTLY--only affects Gremlins directly.-0-
Giving players a new ability doesn't affect them?

>> 485/0 passes (6-1-1).
>> Created 498/2.
>> Created 500/0.
>> Created Guido.
>> Glotmorf(actually me in disguise) scores 11 points.
> -0- True, wouldn't have happened, re:my CFJ -0-

>> 486/0 passes (4-1-3).
>> Created Copper.
>> Created 501/0.
>> Baron von Skippy scores 11 points.
> -0- Ditto. -0-

>> 446/0 passes (7-0).
>> Created 402/1.
>> Created Curt and Rod.
>> The Voice scores 15 points.
> -0- Irrelevant, happened before the changes to r293 took place.
No, it didn't. I checked. (r293 changed at the beginning of nweek 9)
> Anyway, 
> r293 covers it (the player w/Idol can't Climb through the Window).-0-
Again, the proposal may have changed it, but the *rule* didn't.

>> 
>> --Wonko
>> Save the Gremlins!
Ha! Like that's gonna happen.
>> 



--Wonko
Kill the Gremlins!