RE: spoon-discuss: Re: spoon-business: Proosals

["Donald Whytock" <dwhytock@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On 1/7/02 at 5:35 PM Doig, Gavin wrote:

>> Sorry, guy.  Rule 155 says that if a proposal tries to determine who
>voted
>what
>> for itself, all the votes would come from Bob the Voting Fish.  Which
>means all
>> those points you promise would go to Bob too.
>
>No. The proposal does nothing of the sort; it creates a rule which does,
>but
>that's not covered by r155.
>
>uin.

Ah, but the proposal is creating the rule, and the rule is creating the points, which means the proposal is creating the circumstances under which the points are created.  Les'n you can think of a way of creating the rule without a proposal.

Hmm...That just might win me a pink scarf...:)