RE: spoon-discuss: CFJ: The clock...

["Jonathan Van Matre" <JVanMatre@xxxxxxxx>]

A few things stick out, even allowing for your interpretation of the
matter:

1) The primary paradox comes in the administrative headaches involved.
If I search the website history for rules as of nweek 3, what am I going
to get?  Both weeks smushed together on one page?  A 50/50 chance of
seeing one or the other?  

My primary reason for the CFJ is to preserve the sanity of our gracious
administrator, and the integrity of the tools already built for the
website.  

2) Under rule 15/2, since both ballots will be the "nweek 3 ballot" I
should be able to vote on ballots for both this nweek and last nweek,
enabling me to effectively take action in the past.

> I don't really see a conflict here.  Rules 17 and 32 are referring to
> causing events to occur in the past that didn't occur.  Just 
> because the
> nweek is called nweek 3 doesn't mean that anything that 
> happens this nweek
> actually happened last nweek.  Just that we are calling the nweeks the
> same thing.  Its merely a symantic issue, not a paradoxal issue.  
> 
> Just my thoughts, of course, I'm not the judge ;)
> 
> Fenrir