Re: [s-b] [Oracle] CFI 117

[Jeff Gitchel <gitchel@xxxxxxxxx>]

I'd like to point out that I had modified my submission before the previous copy was designated as CFI 117.

My revision of the previous edition - based on discussion with Murphy who was not yet the judge appointed - should not count as a recision of my CFI, since it happened before it was recognized by the Minister. So, I would prefer that my second version be the actual CFI to be judged.

If not, then I will reply that the Judge has not addressed the heart of my CFI, which is that the current (and proposed) Rule 52 severely restricts when a played can come off leave.  

If I may comment on the Proposal here, I do worry about the phrase "except as specified by this rule" since it still seems to say that players cannot announce that they are Off Leave until the Clock is Off.

If the Judge is content with the scope of his ruling, and proposal, and we are to leave Rule 52 as it is (pretty much), then I would like to know if the Rules - which prohibit me from re-submitting the CFI - will let me submit a similar CFI:

CFI - Players may only announce that they are Off Leave when the Clock is Off.



Oh, and what's he mean by "gratuitous"?



 
--  
Jeff Gitchel
jeff@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
http://turtlemoon.org
twitter: gitchel

On 30/06/2010, at 17:01, Ed Murphy <emurphy42@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> JamesB wrote:
> 
>>> From: gitchel@xxxxxxxxx
>>> To: spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
>>> Date: Wed, 30 Jun 2010 13:26:26 -0500
>>> Subject: [s-b] Request for CFI
>>> 
>>> CFI - No player, once On Leave, can declare emself Off Leave, since the condition of being On Leave precludes him from performing any game actions. [Rule 52]
>>> 
>>> Argument: The section in Rule 52 forbidding any game action from players On Leave occurs after the section allowing players to announce that they are Off Leave and, per Rule 36, takes precedence.
>>> 
>> 
>> This is CFI 117. I assign CFI 117 to Judge Murphy. 		 	   		  
> 
> Repeating my gratuitous arguments:
> 
> False, they can do it if the Clock is Off (Rule 52, paragraph 1, last
> sentence, which by Rule 36 takes precedence over the section forbidding
> players On Leave from taking game actions).
> 
> Proposal:  Evergreen
> 
> Amend Rule 52 by replacing this text:
> {{{
> A player who is On Leave cannot be selected by any process which
> randomly selects a player, and may not take any game actions.
> }}}
> with this text:
> {{{
> A player who is On Leave cannot be selected by any process which
> randomly selects a player, and may not take any game actions
> except as specified by this rule.
> }}}
> _______________________________________________
> spoon-business mailing list
> spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
> http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business