Re: [s-b] [s-d] [Society] Non-report.

[Warrigal <ihope127+w@xxxxxxxxx>]

On Wed, Dec 24, 2008 at 6:14 PM, Jamie Dallaire
<bad.leprechaun@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> I submit the following Consultation, naming Rev. Ignoratio Elenchi, KHS as
> Unbeliever:
>
> Question: Does Rev. Ignoratio Elenchi, KHS have m130?
>
> Reasoning:
>
> ((In the message containing eir request to become a Player, but in a
> sentence after the one in which e actually made the request, Rev. Ignoratio
> Elenchi, KHS named himself and Peter as Players responsible for his desire
> to join the game. These Players should therefore get to split the m60
> recruitment bonus evenly, as per Rule 5E18.
>
> The Rule in question, however, specifies that "current" Players may be
> named, and that they must be so named "in" the request to become a Player.
> We may consider that Rev. Ignoratio Elenchi, KHS's message either consisted
> of a single request to become a Player, which contained the naming of
> himself and Peter. We may alternatively consider that his message consisted
> of a request to become a Player, followed by the naming of himself and
> Peter. If we accept the former scenario, I think that the recruitment bonus
> was not awarded because Rev. Ignoratio Elenchi, KHS was not a current Player
> at the time he made the request. If we accept the latter scenario, I think
> that the recruitment bonus was not awarded because Rev. Ignoratio Elenchi,
> KHS did not name himself and Peter in the request itself, but afterwards.
>
> Note that in the first scenario evoked, the question of whether Peter
> received any mack is still up in the air even if Rev. Ignoratio Elenchi, KHS
> did not.))

I assign this Consultation the number 177. (Consultation 176 was an
unofficial Consultation called by Sgeo and assigned to GreenReaper.)

Standing players: none. Sitting players: Charles, JamesB, BobTHJ,
0x44, Murphy, teucer, ehird and Billy Pilgrim.

I rotate the bench, making all Sitting players Standing. I assign
Consultation 177 to Charles.

Further dibs stuff: If you want to blanket dibs out of all future
Consultations by default, go ahead and I'll try not to assign
Consultations to you unless you ask for them. Again, the
standing/sitting thing takes precedence over this.

Standing players: JamesB, BobTHJ, 0x44, Murphy, teucer, ehird and
Billy Pilgrim. Sitting ayers: none.

--Warrigal
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business