[s-b] Consultation done right.

[Josiah Worcester <josiahw@xxxxxxxxx>]

I retract the following consultation, if possible:
{
Registrar Wooble does not have the power to allow Agora to become a player by 
Rule 1-4
}

I submit the following consultation:
{
Does Registrar Wooble have the power to refuse Agora as a player by Rule 1-4?
}
Unbeliever: Wooble
Arguments: 

"The Registrar may refuse to allow any External Force to become a 
player, and may refuse to recognize any otherwise-legal name change, if e 
believes the External Force's proposed name (or existing player's new name) 
would be ambiguous or confusing, or could otherwise damage the integrity of 
this game."

This does not give the Registrar carte blanche license to refuse a new player: 
this only gives the Registrar the power to refuse a name that is ambiguous, 
confusing, or damages the integrity of the game. Since Agora is none of 
these, the Registrar does not have the power to refuse Agora's status as a 
player under this rule.

There is no other rule that gives the Registrar the power to refuse a new 
player.
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business