Re: [s-b] Game Action: Answering a consultation.

[0x4461736864617368 <bnomic@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

As Priest, I'm going to have to request that this Consultation be ZOTTED 
by the Minister of Questions. It may be resubmitted by the supplicant 
with revisions.

Reasoning:

Rule 2-5 requires that the question posed be answerable with a Yes or No 
answer. The question was not posed in such a form as to permit a yes or 
no reply. Should the Priest have answered yes or no, the meaning would 
have been ambiguous.

--
0x4461736864617368;



Jamie Dallaire wrote:
> As much as I like the idea of a Flurry of Peace Doves, I feel constrained,
> as the MiniMinister of Arguments, to submit the following Consultation:
>
> {{
> The Question:
> In the event that a particular Game Action, which may be taken only without
> a certain number of Objections within a certain period of time, is
> successfully performed without said number of Objections, is this Game
> Action considered to have been performed at the time when it reached a
> Public Forum, or at the end of the Objection period?
>
> Reasoning:
> Rule 3-14 states that "the Artisan may, as a Game Action on behalf of the
> Ministry of Goods and without 2 objections within 2 ndays, create a
> blueprint. The Ministry of Goods may only create a single blueprint in a
> given nweek, and can do so no later than Tango [[nday 4]] of that nweek."
> Hose, the current Artisan, sent a message to a Public Forum on nday 4 of
> nweek 133, announcing his intention to create a non-unique Blueprint named
> "Olive Tree". If this Game Action does not receive 2 objections, it may or
> may not fail, depending on whether it is considered to have been performed
> on nday 4 (permissible) or nday 6 (not allowed by Rule 3-14).
>
> Unbeliever:
> Hose
> }}
>
> As Minister of Questions,
>
> I assign this Consultation to a Consultation Number of 68, and select
> 0x4461736864617368 to be the Priest for this Consultation.
>
> Billy Pilgrim
> _______________________________________________
> spoon-business mailing list
> spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
> http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business
>   
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business