[s-b] consultation 17

[Antonio <antonio.dolcetta@xxxxxxxxx>]

if this message is duplicated please ignore it

I submit the following consultation:
{
Supposing there are two
Players, say A and B, where A is a single human being and B is a group
of human beings that contains A, then if A and B vote for the same
proposal only the most recent vote is counted. True or false ?
}
Reasoning:
{
B nomic has traditionally enforced the idea "one man, one vote"
If
a Primo style corporation were allowed to become a player any entity
who is a player by itself and is also part of the corporation would
have a number of votes >1  
Bear with me here:
rule 2-2 states:
- Any Player may submit a Vote on an Open proposal at any time. ...
- The most recent Vote on a proposal by a Player is called that  
- player's Final Vote on that proposal
the intent clearly being to allow only one vote from each player. 
by Rule 1-4
- A Player is an Outsider
and by Rule 1-3
- An Outsider is an External Force
So going back to the consultation's example Player A who is part of B is actually resubmitting his Final vote through B.
}

This is Consultation 17, assigned to BobTHJ






_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business