[Spoon-business] CFI: RE: NWEEK 58 RESULTS

[SkArcher <SkArcher@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

On Tue, 2 Mar 2004 19:51:15 -0600 (CST), David E. Smith 
<dave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

> Sagitta plays SPOO on The Pusher Robot. Two of Pusher's cards go back 
> into
> the Deck.
>
> All players get new cards for a new nweek.
>
> Zarpint's Quote Prop is p1810.
>
> The new Gremlin Number is 105.
>
> At long last, it's nweek 59.

> Proposal 1800/0 (Platonism) (Teucer):
> AFF: Baron von Skippy, bd, Mikie The Inscrutable, Sagitta, Teucer, 
> Zarpint
> NEG: Glotmorf, The Pusher Robot
> ABS: Iain
> SHL: SkArcher
> Counts (Y/N/A/S) : (6-2-1-1). Measure passes. Teucer gains 8 points.
> Created a Philosophical Mandate.

I submit a CFI;


{{statement: Proposal 1800 has no effect.

Plaintiffs analysis: As stated previously, the philosophical mandate 
Platonism does not fulfil the requirements of a Philosophical Mandate. 
Specifically, while it has a "statement of a permission not available to 
players who don't hold that Philosophy" - in this case {{A Platonist may 
vote four times FOR any proposal which was shelved on a previous ballot}} 
- but the only restriction in the Philosophical Mandate is against doing 
something that no Player without Philosophical Mandate could do anyway, 
thus breaching Rule 1252s requirement that "said permission is accompanied 
by a restriction not imposed on players who don't hold that Philosophy"

Proposal 1800 therefore either fails, or has no effect if it passes.

Defendant: Teucer}}


SkArcher
_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business