Re: [Spoon-business] NWEEK 19 BALLOT

["Glotmorf" <glotmorf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

>Proposal 805/0: Dan makes up for eir lack of forethought (Dan)

No.  A Player takes a risk when e proposes, because there's a penalty if it doesn't pass.  This would eliminate the risk.

>Proposal 806/0: Opportunity Knocks: Pseudocode (The Voice)

No.  I still think there's a place for pseudocode actions.

>Proposal 807/0: Recursion Limit (Rob)

Yes.  This prevents infinite stupidity stemming from recursive proposals or recursive pseudocode actions.  Possibly even recursive rules, if it's interpreted the right way.

>Proposal 808/0: Calm down! (The Voice)

No.  Too subjective to be a single player's action.  Better handled as a proposal, perhaps a Disrespect prop.

>Proposal 809/0: Neatening Up: The Grid (Wonko)

Shelve.  You neglected to mention the List of Grid Substances, which, BTW, doesn't currently contain Turf.  You also are saying players can't move to squares that contain other players, but, especially with subsection C, players can be Elbonia-thrown into squares with other players.  Also, the cheerleaders you mention have been eliminated.

>Proposal 810/0: Gnomes for sale! (Wonko)

No.  There should still be a way to purchase a random gnome.

>Proposal 811/0: Sushi Forfeiture (M-Tek)

Yes.

>Proposal 816/0: Introducing Physical Law (Dan)

No.  This is unchanged from the version we shelved last nweek.

>Proposal 818/0: Flipping The Circuit Breaker (Rob)

Yes.  It'll cut down the panics.

>Proposal 820/1: Let's Take A Look at the BIG Channel 6 Weather Map! (The
>Voice)

Yes.  Though I'll want to see the hair.

>Proposal 822/1: You Won't Have DimShips to Kick Around Any More (Glotmorf)

Yes, dammit.  15.

>Proposal 823/0: Thanks For All The Memories (Baron von Skippy)

Abstain.  Thank you, though.

>Proposal 824/1: Hurg (bd)

No.  Why in the name of Harlan Ellison's accumulated earwax would we want to do this?

>Proposal 826/1: And Break Every Rung On The Way Up (Glotmorf)

Yes,

>Proposal 827/4: Preemptive Less Is More: The Force (Wonko)

Shelve.  B8 and B9 just seem too powerful to me.

>Proposal 829/0: More Is More, Nweek <nweek #> (The Administrator)

Yes.

>Proposal 831/0: Lots o' Points! (The Administrator)

No.

>Proposal 832/1: Uin Would Be Proud (The Administrator)

No.  There is no reason to destroy the societies rules.

>Proposal 833/1: The Neutron Proposal (Glotmorf)

Yes.

>Proposal 834/1: Corrections (bd)

No.  The clarification is still useful.

>Proposal 835/0: Cleaning up everything (Wonko)

No.  This doesn't mesh well with p843, and I can make a case for non-voting gremlin members, and even voting gremlin members, and then it would have to be changed back. Give it another nweek.

>Proposal 836/0: Now, Then, Where Was I? (Baron von Skippy)

Shelve.  See below.

>Proposal 837/0: On the Rocks/Shaken, not Stirred (Baron von Skippy)

Yes, pending passage of 836; otherwise Shelve.

>Proposal 838/0: Friends Don't Let Friends Play Nomic Drunk (Baron von
>Skippy)

Shelve.  Why create a game-legal action, the performance of which earns a Kick in the Ass?

>Proposal 839/0: What the hell is an issue? (M-Tek)

Yes.

>Proposal 841/0: Fixing the Past (Wonko)

No.  I still don't like that sentence about "The Administrator may prevent..." and I never did like the part about "the gamestate shall be altered to what they now would be".

>Proposal 842/1: You know, I can't think of a witty title for this one, so
>		I'll call it the Ministry of Gnomes Proposal (Baron von Skippy)

Shelve.  This time.  Still too much get-rich-quick-and-easy potential.

>Proposal 843/1: fixing stupid stuff that should have been fixed earlier
>(Dan)

Yes.

>Proposal 844/0: Less is More: Dimensions (Glotmorf)

Yes.

>Proposal 845/1: Will Shomeone Hold Thish *hic* Ballot Shtill? (Glotmorf)

Yes.

>Proposal 846/1: Copycat! (The Voice)

No.  Still leery about multiple tokens of proposal.  And Bruce.

>Proposal 847/0: GremBall Jumpstart (The Voice)

Yes.

>Proposal 848/0: Population Control: The Aftermath (The Voice)

Yes.

						Glotmorf


_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business