spoon-discuss: RE: spoon-business: RFJ #37

["Harrison, Andrew" <andy.harrison@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Unfortunately you're too late, you were just recused from that!

--
The Kid


> -----Original Message-----
> From: Chess [mailto:chess@xxxxxxxxxxxx]
> Sent: 28 March 2001 18:31
> To: 'Nomic Business'
> Subject: spoon-business: RFJ #37
> 
> 
> [[I may as well rule on this properly, given I've done it 
> once already...]]
> 
> RFJ:
> > > "The Player Poulenc performed several actions after the 
> Motive Order
> > > for repayment was issued, and therefore did not perform the
> > > required action
> > > 'as soon as possible' as stated in Rule 319/0."
> 
> Judgement: true
> 
> Analysis:
> The action required to repay the debt (which the Player 
> Poulenc was able to
> do as e had enough points) was to post a message to a public 
> forum stating
> that the points are transferred. As Poulenc posted other 
> messages to public
> fora before posting this message or the equivalent (i.e. 
> before the points
> were transferred) I feel justified in assuming that he was capable of
> posting the required message, and as he did not do so before 
> carrying out
> other similar actions he obviously did not perform the 
> required action 'as
> soon as possible'.
> 
> [[I could have argued for false as well, citing vagueness of 
> 'as soon as
> possible' and admissibility of all that isn't strictly 
> prohibited, but as
> this is too late to affect anything anyway...]]
>