[s-b] [Fwd: Re: Nweek 112 ballot]

["David E. Smith" <dave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

--- Begin Message ---

• To: spoon-discuss@xxxxxxxxx
• Subject: Re: [s-b] Nweek 112 ballot
• From: "David E. Smith" <dave@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
• Date: Mon, 27 Nov 2006 22:21:30 -0600
• In-reply-to: <ulklwe8az.fsf@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
• References: <ulklwe8az.fsf@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
• User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.2; en-US; rv:1.8.0.7) Gecko/20060909 Thunderbird/1.5.0.7 Mnenhy/0.7.4.0

Peter Cooper Jr. wrote:

1	The Eras of B Nomic

FOR, even though it doesn't seem to, like, do anything.

2	Define Winning

FOR. What's the point of a game if you can't win?

3	it's the game of B!

AGAINST. Nostalgia.

4	R.O.B.O.T.S. : Robots on Bnomic offer Total Suffering

AGAINST. It's too early in the game to get this silly.

5	Properties

FOR. Hopefully we can do something even cooler with it later on.

6	Quote Fun

AGAINST. p15 does it better.

7	Conflict resoluton

AGAINST. Tries to do too many things at once, and most of them are done poorly.

8	Hard rules

AGAINST. This rule is hard... to understand.

9	Attributes

AGAINST. Conflicts with p12, and I (humbly) think I did it better ;)

10	boring proposal precedence

FOR. It's wordy and I'm down with wordy.

11	Remove Revision Numbers

FOR. I don't want things to be TOO wordy...

12	A winner is you!

FOR. I think I just figured out how to make the last sentence work, and in the meantime the slightly-ambiguous wording shouldn't break anything, because there's not yet anything in the game that creates or transfers Points.

13	Name-change props

AGAINST. The last sentence is impossibly ambiguous. The last thing we need is a State of Emergency in the first nweek.

14	Change bd's name

FOR. Quit trying to break the game, asshat.

15	Finite search space

FOR. This is the least sucky of the "name" props.

16	Emergency Management Procedure

FOR. It's not perfect but it's a start.

17	Judgment, the actual proposal

AGAINST. I'm working on a better version, and I'm hoping like Hell we don't need it in the next nweek.

18	you must be able to retract your proposal

AGAINST. One of the other props makes "turn a prop Historical" trigger a vote count, and I'm hedging my bets.

19	Infinite search space

AGAINST. p15 does it better.

20	Retroactive thing.

AGAINST. I fear things I don't understand.

dave

--- End Message ---

_______________________________________________
spoon-business mailing list
spoon-business@xxxxxxxxx
http://lists.ellipsis.cx/mailman/listinfo/spoon-business